Darling and Rotten are at nearly opposite ends of the scale this time, an unusual situation indeed. Will they reconcile? Are there more spats looming in the future? Stay Tuned!

Boys First Time has been around a long, long time, and while it was ground breaker circa 2002, it no longer occupies the top spot in the "all kinds of guys fucking" heap.

It's still a somewhat likable place, primarily due to the early stuff still on the server. The photosets you'll find on the last page of the member area still have some good heat, although the videos from this classic stuff are what you'd expect from material of that age.

Here's the good old "however comma" statement: Boys First Time is quickly losing it's charm, due to upsells and a general "mass production" attitude regarding content - as time goes by, more episodes are featuring roadworn warhorse performers than newcomers.

There are some hotties, some average "joes," and a few whom I'll describe as falling somewhat short of being attractive when using the common acceptance of that term.

As a final comment, I'll add that the site now appears to be edited by straight people who seem to have little understanding of what us fudgepackers consider entertaining.

Boys First Time made me 

To paraphrase Chevy Chase, "Rotten Ray, you slut!" I totally disagree with your assessment of Boys First Time.

It's an amateur site filmed by amateur photographers. Unlike many which place a disproportionate emphasis on pretty boys with humongous cocks, the young men that I saw look like the same guys that I see when I go out to local clubs, aka "attainable." That's it's charm. Sure, there are some that are coyote ugly - but face it, we all have fucked one in a drunken stupor. And many are hotties I would love to lure to my den of iniquity. Granted, there is little creativity or variety of script or plot, but this is amateur porn dammit, not a Warner Brothers or Falcon production. That said, the heavy shadows surrounding the models are totally inexcusable and very distracting even for an amateur production.

In my test drive, I enjoyed the fact that the camera angles were excellent in capturing the action. If guys are fucking, I want to see dick going in and out of ass. I want a clear view of the blow job, not of the back of someone's head. The videos accomplished that well. What I did not like about the videos was the chatter, almost directional at times, between the photographer and the guys and in some a clicking camera that both caused me to lose my concentration ;-) at times.

Boys First Time is what it is... an amateur site with amateur performers in hot action filmed by amateur photographers. Its native content is abundant. It accomplishes its mission.

Boys First Time made me 

Boys First Time also offers upsells to Bait Bus and Ethan Rivers, both of which are a bit past their heyday.